Ethical Decision-Making Process

You and your partner are detectives working in plain clothes. For several days, you have been staking out an elementary school playground where an adult male reportedly has been approaching the children. One particular morning, you have observed a man in his car parked alongside the school yard. When he calls a little girl over to his car and she approaches him on the driver's side, you exit from your unmarked vehicle and approach his vehicle from the passenger side so that he cannot see you easily in his rear view mirror. When you get just behind his car on the passenger side, you observe that he has his pants open. With his left hand, he is stroking the girl's hair.

You call for your partner over the radio and move to arrest the suspect. Showing him your badge, you order him to close his pants and get out of his car. You handcuff him and place him in the back of your unmarked vehicle, while your partner returns the girl to the safekeeping of school administrators.

After telling the suspect of his right to remain silent, you begin interrogating him, recording his name, address, and so forth while awaiting your partner's return.

When your partner comes back, he gets in the rear of your vehicle with the suspect (a violation of department regulations, unless there is reason to believe that the passenger is suicidal). You remind your partner that riding in the back is a violation of the rules, but he stays there anyway; tells you to drive to the station; and turning to the suspect, calls him a "maggot." As you drive, your partner starts punching the suspect repeatedly in the face and the crotch. He even leans back and, bracing himself against the car door, kicks the suspect in the chest and shoulders with the heel of his shoe. When the suspect turns to avoid the blows, your partner kicks him in the back and kidney areas. Throughout this beating, the suspect offers no resistance of any kind. You hear the sounds of the beating and, looking in the rear view mirror, you see your partner striking the suspect. After about a minute, you pull the vehicle over, open the rear door and persuade your partner to get out of the back seat and come sit beside you in the front.

After the suspect is booked and in a holding cell, your partner tells you he will write a report that includes the assertion that the child molester forcefully resisted arrest and sustained injuries during the scuffle to handcuff him. He tells you that he will write the report and sign it, and that you do not have to be associated with its contents.

At his trial, the offender pleads guilty to child molestation charges and is sentenced to 3 years in prison, to be served at a treatment center for sexual offenders. Soon afterwards, your partner is sued by the offender for physical abuse and injury. Claiming kidney damage, loss of two teeth, civil rights violations, and psychological trauma, the convicted molester is asking a civil (not a criminal) court for an award of $2 million from your department and $500,000 from your partner. You receive a subpoena from the court to appear at the trial. In addition, the Internal Affairs Division will launch its own investigation of the allegations, and it informs you that you will be called in to make a statement under oath at a hearing about the events. If the department finds sufficient grounds to believe that your partner acted brutally, he will be suspended, or more likely, fired; if the civil jury finds that he was abusive, he may be forced to sell his home and car to pay the award to the victim. You may also be disciplined for failure to protect your prisoner. Comments in the locker room by other officers make it clear that, given the nature of the victim, they expect you to do whatever is necessary to protect your partner from being held accountable, as well as to protect yourself.

Assignment Guidelines

  • What are your options with regard to the above scenario?
    • List each option, and provide a brief explanation of the benefits and consequences for selecting that option.
  • How would you apply the following factors to the scenario?
    • Intentions
    • Seemliness
    • Proportionality
    • Minimization
    • Practicability
  • Research the standard of objectivity.
    • How does the standard of objectivity apply, especially as it relates to personal feelings?
  • How would you respond under these circumstances?
    • Outline your decision-making process using ethical decision-making guidelines.
    • Be sure to address the counterpoints to your arguments and why you decided against them.
  • Be sure to reference all sources using APA style.

Please submit your assignment.

Answers

Related Questions

Management : Logistics System...

BACK BONE OF INDUTRIESLOGISTICS MEANING IMPORTANCE LOGISTICS AND BUSINESSLOGISTICS RESASON FOR IMPORTANCE OF LOGISTICS CUSTOMERS ATTITUDE ADVANCEMENT...

Psychology : Security Staff...

NameCourseTutorDateRunning Head: POLICE FORCE RECRUITMENTSecurity StaffInterview questions1. Why do you want to work with this industry?I have always...

History : History2...

Save and SubmitQUE ST ION 11.Match the term/concept to the correct description.D.G.F.I.C.H.E.RenaissanceManAnswerA. the beliefthat if one nationsuccum...

History : History...

QUE ST ION 11.Match the term/concept to the correct description.AnswerRead Answer Items A. an attack thatfor Question 1took place duringJ.SputnikI.dem...

Business : Sports Management...

Surname 1NameCourseTutorDateUnderstanding of Drugs and AlcoholOver the last few years, there has been an explosion of drug and alcohol usein the count...

Business : Business Development...

Running head: BUSINESS DEVELOPMENTBusiness DevelopmentName of StudentInstitutional Affiliation1BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT2Business DevelopmentBusiness theor...

Business : Project Planning And Developmentt...

Running head: PROJECT PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENTProject Planning and ManagementName of StudentInstitutional Affiliation1PROJECT PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT...

Accounting : Order Number Mzgaffdbz...

Running head: CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTSConsolidated Financial StatementsAuthors nameInstitutional affiliations1CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMEN...

Writing : New...

LIBERTY UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF DIVINITYResearch Paper Part 3Submitted to Dr.,in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the completion ofGLST 650 D0...

Geology : Los Angeles California 1...

"Los Angeles, California (1/17/1994)Earthquake"NameInstitutional AffiliationIntroduction/BackgroundOn January 17, 1994, the first earthquake since 193...

Health & Medical : Him Proposal...

Running Head: Health Information ImprovementRunning Head: Health Information ImprovementYour nameInstructor nameCourseSubmission date1Running Head: He...

Marketing : R956 Integrated Marketing Communicatio...

Running head: INTEGRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATIONS APPROACH TRENDSIntegrated Marketing Communications Approach TrendsInstitution AffiliationDate1INTEGR...

Sociology : Order 14564729...

1Running head: GRADUATE TOOLS FACILITATING SUCCESSGraduate Tools Facilitating SuccessStudents NameInstitution2GRADUATE TOOLS FACILITATING SUCCESSGradu...

Health & Medical : Shareholder Analysis Final...

Running Head: Stakeholder Communication in Health Information SystemsYour nameInstructor nameCourseSubmission date1Running Head: Stakeholder Communica...

Computer Science : Cloud Alternative...

Alternative Cloud SolutionNameDateSummary of Cloud Vendors Cloud technology has enjoyed massive popularity over the lasttwo decades. Currently, there...

Health & Medical : Nursing Practice Problem...

Running head: DISCUSSION1DiscussionNameCourseProfessorDateDISCUSSION2Nursing Practice ProblemThe difference between a nursing practice problem and a m...

Nursing : Final Paper Issues And Trends Dayana...

Issues and Trends in Nursing1The Impaired NurseDayana Gonzalez ChamizoWest Coast UniversityNURS 4406th August 2019NURS 4402The Impaired NurseIn the pa...

Sociology : Order 14564417...

1Running head: WRITING IN PSYCHOLOGY AND RELEVANCE OF SOURCESWriting In Psychology and Relevance of SourcesStudents NameInstitution2WRITING IN PSYCHOL...

Computer Science : Snmp...

Running head: SNMPSNMPNameCourseTutorDateSNMP2SNMPSNMP (Simple Network Management Protocol) is regarded as a standard protocol on theinternet for coll...

Business : Team Effectiveness .edited.docx Edited...

Running Head: TEAM EFFECTIVENESSTeam EffectivenessStudents NameInstitutional Affiliation1TEAM EFFECTIVENESS2Team effectiveness1. What Colin could have...

History : Chicago Bib 3...

1Encounters and Interactions between Europeans and Native Americans under the Sphere of theMarketplace in Colonial New England focusing on Fur TradeNa...

Computer Science : Public Key Encryption Attacks.e...

Running head: PUBLIC KEY ENCRYPTION ATTACKS1Public Key Encryption AttacksStudents NameProfessors NameCourse TitleDatePUBLIC KEY ENCRYPTION ATTACKS2Pub...

Management : Zurich Case Study...

Running head: ZURICH CASE STUDY1Zurich Case StudyStudents NameProfessors NameCourse TitleDateZURICH CASE STUDY2Zurich Case StudyERM tools at Zurich ar...

Management : 15501705 Leadership.edited...

Running head: LEADERSHIP AND LEADERSHIP QUALITIESLeadership and leadership qualitiesNameInstitution affiliatedDate1LEADERSHIP AND LEADERSHIP QUALITIES...

If you didn't find the right answer

Ask Your Questions, We'll notify you once someone answers it